Fluoride vs Hydroxyapatite: What you Really Need to Know

ROS Admin | December 7, 2023

flouride vs hydroxyapatite
In the ever-evolving world of dental care, staying informed about the best products for your oral health is crucial. Today, let’s unravel the mystery between two key ingredients that have been the talk of the town in dental circles: Fluoride and Hydroxyapatite. Both have their unique advantages, but understanding their roles and how they work can significantly impact your dental care choices.

Fluoride: The Trusted Warrior in Dental Defense

The Crucial Role of Fluoride in Oral Health

Fluoride is the veteran in the realm of dental care. Revered for its ability to fortify tooth enamel and thwart decay, it acts as a shield for your teeth against the daily onslaught of bacteria and acids. By aiding in the remineralization process, Fluoride not only repairs weakened enamel but also helps prevent the formation of cavities. When Fluoride is present in the mouth it will actually change the composition of hydroxyapatite (the main component of enamel) to form fluorapatite– which is less soluble, meaning it is better able to withstand demineralization.

Water Fluoridation

In the 1930s, research found that children who drank water with higher levels of Fluoride had less tooth decay. In 1945, Michigan was the first state to add Fluoride to the public water supply. In 2020, over 70% of communities with public water systems had access to fluoridated water. Due to the dramatic decline in dental decay that followed water fluoridation, the CDC named it as 1 of the 10 great public health achievements of the 1900s.

Why Fluoride Remains a Dental Care Staple

Fluoride’s popularity stems from its proven track record in reducing cavity risks, especially in children, who benefit from its enamel-strengthening properties as their teeth develop. For adults, Fluoride has been an essential ally in combating years of dietary and lifestyle habits that can affect dental health. The research on Fluoride for the prevention of tooth decay is robust– that fact cannot be denied. For this reason, Fluoride is still the “go-to” taught at dental schools across the world for the prevention of cavities.

Why has Fluoride become Controversial

You may have noticed a warning sign on the back of your tube of toothpaste with a reference to poison control. As with many approved ingestible ingredients, Fluoride can be toxic in high doses. The body weight of the person ingesting the Fluoride is a key factor to consider when determining its safety. This is why a lot of infant and toddler “training” toothpastes don’t contain any Fluoride. Because children’s toothpastes typically have a good flavor, children have been known to sneakily “eat” it. If you end up catching your child with a half empty tube of toothpaste, poison control will most likely end up asking for your child’s weight, how much they consumed, and then tell you to give your child some milk or yogurt since calcium binds to Fluoride. Nowadays, Fluoride “toxicity” and things like fluorosis have become more worrisome due to the uncontrolled amounts of fluoride in the water supply in certain areas. Though Fluoride has been found to be a neurotoxin, it really depends on the dosage, which is what makes many people’s argument on toothpaste difficult. Because if the correct amount of Fluoride toothpaste is used – a smear for kids under the age of 3 and a pea-sized amount for those 3 and older – then you don’t have anything to worry about.

Hydroxyapatite: The Natural Alternative for Dental Care

The Innovative Role of Hydroxyapatite

Hydroxyapatite, a relatively new contender in dental care, is making waves due to its natural composition. This mineral, which forms the majority of tooth enamel and bone, offers a more organic approach to tooth care. Its inclusion in dental products is seen as a progressive step towards harnessing natural elements to rebuild and fortify tooth enamel.

The Unique Benefits of Hydroxyapatite in Oral Hygiene

Hydroxyapatite’s edge lies in its high biocompatibility, seamlessly integrating with the body’s natural processes. When incorporated into dental products, it adheres to the enamel, filling in tiny imperfections and rebuilding the tooth’s surface. This not only strengthens teeth but also restores their natural whiteness. As a fluoride-free option, Hydroxyapatite is gaining popularity among those who prefer a holistic approach to dental care.

How Solid is the Research behind Hydroxyapatite

The truth is, there is still a lot of research that needs to be done on the specific form and dosage of Hydroxyapatite used in the new toothpastes on the market. It is important to note that there are different forms being used, nano-Hydroxyapatite and micro-Hydroxyapatite. Nano-hydroxyapatite has been around longer, and has even been used by astronauts. However, it is technically a synthetic form of Hydroxyapatite and therefore has limits on the dosages that can be used. You will see in the market that there are different dosages being utilized and the research is growing. Because it is much smaller, it has been shown to help with sensitivity, as it is able to enter smaller spaces. On the other hand, micro-Hydroxapatite is derived from natural materials and therefore is available in higher dosages. It seems to help with remineralization as does Fluoride, but higher level research is still needed.

What about the other Ingredients?

In the grand scheme of things, what we really need to worry about is some of the other ingredients used in traditional toothpastes. As “cleaner” choices are becoming a warranted trend, we should be aware of certain ingredients such as sodium lauryl sulfate, artificial dyes, triclosan, parabens, and carrageenan. Most of the cleaner brands are incorporating Hydroxyapatite instead of Fluoride, but there are still some brands out there with cleaner options that still contain Fluoride.

Deciding Between Fluoride and Hydroxyapatite: A Personal Choice

The debate between Fluoride and Hydroxyapatite isn’t about which is better, but rather, which is more suitable for your specific dental needs. Fluoride’s proven efficacy in preventing cavities makes it a reliable choice for high-risk individuals. Conversely, Hydroxyapatite’s natural composition offers a gentle yet effective option for those who prefer a fluoride-free regimen.

Tailoring Your Dental Care to Your Needs

Choosing between Fluoride and Hydroxyapatite involves considering factors like cavity risk, personal health choices, and lifestyle. If you live in an area without fluoridated water, have a water filtration system, or are prone to cavities, Fluoride might be the way to go. If you’re inclined towards a natural dental routine or have fluoride sensitivities, consider Hydroxyapatite. You can also mix it up and use a Hydroxyapatite toothpaste throughout the day but use a Fluoride toothpaste (preferably one without SLS and artificial dyes) at night before bed. Whether you opt for Fluoride, Hydroxyapatite, or seek advice from experts like Dr. Ricci, the key is to make informed choices that suit your individual dental and health needs. Embrace the advancements in dental care and orthodontics, and let your smile shine with confidence!

Embracing the Future of Orthodontics with Dr. Ricci

Ready to Transform Your Smile?

In the journey of achieving the perfect smile, having the right guidance is crucial. Dr. Ricci, an expert in the field of orthodontics, is here to lead you towards a more confident smile. Whether you’re just exploring options, ready to take the plunge, or seeking expert dental advice, it’s time to take action.

Schedule Your Complimentary Consultation Today

Don’t wait any longer to achieve the smile you’ve always dreamed of. Reach out for a complimentary consultation with Dr. Ricci. With cutting-edge techniques and a personalized approach, she is dedicated to crafting that ideal smile for you. Embrace the future of orthodontics and embark on a transformative journey with Dr. Ricci.
Prev Post

Next Post